4.1 Audit and Risk Committee
The minutes of the Committee meeting of 10 February 2023 were noted and Board member and Audit & Risk Committee (ARC) member Michelle O’Sullivan, in the absence of the Committee Chair, provided a verbal report on the matters considered at the Committee meeting that took place on 24 March 2023.
Ms O’Sullivan advised the Board that the Committee reviewed and noted 3 briefing papers relating to Cost of Care of Publicly Managed Beds; Ethics Disclosures (management assurance re compliance with SIPO Returns and related matters) and the Memorandum of Understanding with the Charities Regulator, which had all been considered previously by the Committee.
The CEO, Stephen Mulvany, and Board members Tim Hynes & Dr Sarah McLoughlin joined the meeting for the discussion of potential advices by ARC to the Board re NSP funding including budgeting and performance reporting 2023 on the NSP 2023, and the advices from the Committee are included in the ARC section of the Board papers, previously circulated.
The Committee reviewed and approved the final draft of the Protected Disclosures Annual Report 2022, which is a statutory report that has to be published by 31 March each year.
The Board were advised that the Committee reviewed and recommended to the Board the Quarter 4 Corporate Risk Register; the final draft of the HSE Enterprise Risk Management Policy and Procedures 2023; 3 papers concerning banking arrangements and the 1 st draft of the Annual Financial Statements which are all included under the Reserved Functions for the Boards approval.
The Committee received a number of updates in relation to Health Budget Oversight Group, Report on 2022 Review of Effectiveness of System of Internal Control within the HSE, Controls Assurance Review Process, Corporate Procurement Plan June 22 – oversight of progress against deliverables and Progress of self- assessment of non- compliant procurement 2022, which will continue to be on the Committee’s agenda.
An update was received by the Committee from the ND IA, and presented to the Committee was an ICT Audit briefing from Mazars which provided an annual update on ICT Audit activity and an update on the present regulatory environment pertaining to IT Audit and IT Audit trends and risks.
The Committee noted the revised version of the Programme Assurance Plan of the New Children’s Hospital - Governance Paper in relation to the positioning of the Board and ARC in the Plan, and also discussed Owenacurra, particularly in relation to the management controls of taking capacity out of the system and agreed that a further discussion would be required on this, which would include the COO.
The Committee noted a paper presented by the CSO, and considered the position in relation to the need to increase inpatient accommodation across the acute hospital sector nationally over the remainder of 2023 and 2024.
The Committee considered the existing thresholds for property transactions requiring EMT/ARC/Board approval, and recommended an amendment to these thresholds and also considered the detail of 7 proposed Property Transactions, which they agreed to recommend to the Board which will be discussed later in the Board meeting under Reserved Functions.
4.2 People & Culture Committee
The minutes of the Committee meeting of 13 January 2023 and HR Dashboard were noted and the Committee Chairperson provided a verbal report on the matters considered at the Committee meeting that took place on 10 March 2023.
The People & Culture Committee Chairperson advised the Board that the CEO was in attendance for some parts of the Committee meeting. The Committee received an update on the progress of the Regional Health Areas, and that RHA high-level functional design is now substantially complete, and further work will take place over the coming weeks across Operations, Strategy and Clinical to agree detailed functions and required structures, and the recruitment of the 6 RHA CEOs will be progressed through the Public Appointments Service when sanctioned. The Committee discussed the importance of the branding of the RHAs.
The Committee Chairperson advised the Board that the new public-only Hospital Consultant Contract is in place since the 8 March 2023, and the Committee were provided with an overview of the overall contract and informed that the Local implementation groups have been set up in each CHO and Hospital Group. Also following on from a Committee request at the January meeting the Committee were provided with data on staff compliance with mandatory training, and welcomed high levels of improvements in some areas, but held discussions regarding the low levels of compliance within the areas of cyber security training. The Committee will be further briefed at their next meeting.
The Committee were updated on the status of the continued roll out of NiSRP with successful go live in the South for 18,000 staff, and noted that a Business Case is now in development which will establish the delivery to all Section 38 Agencies. The Committee also reviewed and discussed the data in relation to their request for a Pay & Conditions comparative benchmarking exercise across other jurisdictions.
The Committee were provided an update on the HSE Corporate Risks Q4 2022 report in relation to the three corporate risks assigned to the Committee. The Committee welcomed a presentation from HR officials of CHO Midlands Louth Meath, and Dublin South, Kildare & West Wicklow and the Director of HR Saolta University Health Care Group with regard to some of the supports available to staff which enhance staff morale and service delivery.
4.3 Planning and Performance Committee
The minutes of the Committee meeting of 17 February 2023 were noted and Committee Chairman provided a verbal report on the matters considered at the Committee meeting that took place on 22 March 2023.
He advised that the topics discussed were similar to that of the February meeting and comprised of the ‘Roadmap for Service Improvement of Children’s Disability Services 2023 – 2025’ and the Disability Services Board Paper, which is the subject of today’s ‘Board Strategic Focus’. He advised the Board that the Committee had extensive input into the Roadmap and ongoing communications with the COO and officials, and that they would continue to discuss this very important subject of Progressing Disability Services until it is resolved.
The CEO advised that the Board that he is meeting with the Minister of State for Disability at the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth (DCEDIY) in the coming weeks, and the policy direction of the Disability Roadmap would be made clear after this meeting.
4.4 Safety & Quality Committee
The minutes of the Committee meeting of 10th February 2023 and the January Quality Profile were noted and the Safety and Quality Committee Chairperson provided a verbal report on the matters considered at the Committee meeting that took place on 24th March 2023.
The Chair advised that the “Patient Safety Strategy (PSS) 2019 – 2024 Progress update on delivery of the strategy commitments” was presented by the NQPS Leadership team and an update on the Patient Safety Bill was also provided. The Committee considered if the six key commitments of the Patient Safety Strategy should form the basis of the Committees work plan themes for the remainder of the year.
The Chair advised that the Clinical Lead provided a Programme overview of the NCP ‘People with Disability’ (NCPPD) Programme and the HSE Lead for Open Disclosure presented a summary of the key developments from the HSE Open Disclosure Programme 2022, as outlined in detail in the Annual Report for 2022.
The Chair advised that the Quality Profile from the January data cycle was considered and that a discussion was held about the length of timeframes that are set in metrics. The ND Quality and Patient Safety advised that targets are based on best practice and consider service limitations.
The National Clinical Director, Integrated Care, Clinical Design & Innovation provided an update on the National Clinical Programme from the perspective of Priorities, Risks/Challenges and Modernised Care Pathways and an overview of scheduled Care Modernised Care Pathways was provided. The Chair reported that it was advised that an Integrated IT system was due to go to tender at the end of 2023/start of 2024.
The Chair reported that the Chief Clinical Officer report included an update on winter viruses and advised that Covid 19 activity remains stable and low. Updates were also provided on NSS and CervicalCheck, Our Lady’s Hospital Navan, Cariban and the administration of intravenous Antibiotics in Residential Care.
The Chair briefed the Board on an NiRP report which was commissioned in August 2020 relating to an elderly resident of a HSE nursing home. NiRP made six recommendations and the ND Community Operations provided the Committee with an update on them. The Committee agreed to a detailed presentation on Adult Safeguarding April.
4.5 Technology and Transformation Committee
The Committee Chair advised that there was no March meeting of the Technology & Transformation Committee.
The Chair advised that the Committee is due to hold a workshop on 13 April to discuss the development of the Transformation Roadmap and extended an invitation to members of the Board to attend the workshop. The scope of the workshop is to review the key existing transformation programmes in the context of how they contribute to the strategic priorities of the HSE, the risks associated with their implementation, and the dependencies that they have on other initiatives and enablers. In preparation for this workshop, PwC are engaging with a Reference Group of senior stakeholders, as well as the owners of the transformation programmes concerned.
The CTTO advised the Board that the CIO & IT Leaders Awards 2023 were held on Thursday 30th March, and the HSE won an award under Crisis Leadership for the HSE Ukraine Data and Informatics project.